Issue 95: Contradiction in 2nd para of GETATTR description - NFSv4.1 Issue Tracker

Title	Contradiction in 2nd para of GETATTR description
Priority	required	Status	editing
Superseder		Nosy List	dnoveck, lisaweek, samf, spencer.shepler
Assigned To	spencer.shepler	Topics	3530bis

Created on 2006-07-28.20:25:36 by dnoveck, last changed 2007-02-06.00:55:27 by dnoveck.

Messages
msg496 (view)	Author: dnoveck	Date: 2007-02-06.00:55:27
Checedinto cvs.
msg234 (view)	Author: dnoveck	Date: 2006-07-28.20:25:36
The 2nd paragraph of the description for GETATTR contradicts itself. It says you must return a value if you support an attribute and then talks about what you must do when you can't. It isn't clear from the text what is or isn't allowed for such cases as GETATTRing the ACL attribute when there is no ACL. This needs to be clarified.

History
Date	User	Action	Args
2007-02-06 00:55:40	dnoveck	set	status: need-text -> editing nosy: + spencer.shepler messages: + msg496 assignedto: dnoveck -> spencer.shepler
2007-02-02 16:51:40	dnoveck	set	status: unread -> need-text
2006-08-22 15:21:15	dnoveck	set
2006-08-02 05:00:21	lisaweek	set	nosy: + lisaweek
2006-07-28 21:59:20	samf	set	nosy: + samf
2006-07-28 20:25:36	dnoveck	create